Peer into the UK's illicit tobacco business

Jun 15, 2022 Leave a message

Vice published an article on the problem of illegal tobacco in the UK: "Criminal gangs have made billions selling illegal tobacco in abandoned shops." They said: "Phil Mykytiuk has spent ten years mapping tobacco-related criminal gangs in the north of England. He was new to the job as trading standards manager at Bolton Council in Greater Manchester, but had worked for 10 years on the tobacco control team at nearby Rochdale Council.

"The National Crime Agency says that while it supports tobacco enforcement by partner agencies, it focuses on prohibited products such as drugs and firearms, while HMRC [UK Inland Revenue] is in the lead. However, Mykytiuk believes that the multiple layers of crime behind cheap and illegal tobacco are evading scrutiny, emboldying criminal gangs to expand their power base under the noses of the police for lack of deterrence. After watching Kurdish tobacco gang members invest heavily in real estate and major businesses here in the UK, he now sees evidence that they are moving into cannabis farms.

"But forget drugs," he said. "The medicine was yesterday. The most important are the tobacco smuggling groups. These gangs are becoming some of the most capable criminals in the country. Right now, this is the biggest threat we face."

As the article points out, official statistics show that the illegal market is large (17%) but has not grown in recent years. Maybe, maybe not. Official statistics are based on fuzzy estimates that are sensitive to the assumptions in the model. The government could sample waste to see how many parcels are not being sold legally in the UK. I suspect this would give a larger, more realistic estimate, but HMRC has no interest in knowing what is really going on.

Today, tobacco taxes are so ridiculously high that it is hard to imagine a high rate of "tax morale" among smokers. In any case, they may feel a moral obligation to deprive governments that discriminate against them of money.