Regulation of safer nicotine consumption products could prevent thousands of deaths each year while boosting socio-economic development in Latin America. However, several countries in the region continue to oppose this view, opting for prohibitionism for more than a decade, failing to gain significant fiscal and tax revenues and, more seriously, losing access to health care relevant to these consumers. Products.
In many cities in the region, it is easy to find copies of adulterated products or imported liquids in any market or exhibition, which poses a direct risk to the health of consumers and a minor public health problem. In fact, millions of consumers in most South American countries continue to use unregulated e-cigarette products without any quality control.
Regulatory initiatives in the region can ensure the protection of the health of the growing number of e-cigarette users by providing legal products that meet safety and quality standards to minimize or eliminate problems associated with the illicit market while helping to overcome the economic crisis.
In this series, the situation of e-cigarettes in several Latin American countries will be analyzed in order to understand their current and future prospects from representatives of civil society organizations.
Preventable causes of 47,700 deaths per year
Despite a linear and gradual decrease in tobacco consumption recorded since 2005, tobacco use continues to affect the lives of approximately 9 million Argentines. According to a recent survey conducted by government ministers, the country is the second largest consumer of tobacco in the United States. Argentina is second only to Chile, with a consumption prevalence of over 22.2% in 2018, which is also the lowest in the region over the past decade: 25%, compared to a 44% drop in Chile and a 47% drop in Paraguay.
Argentines typically start smoking at the age of 12, according to the Argentine American Heart Foundation (FIC). One in five young people aged 13 to 15 smokes. In addition, 6,000 non-smokers die from second-hand exposure, while the smoking epidemic causes nearly 48,000 deaths each year.
Chronic noncommunicable diseases (CNCD) associated with smoking, such as cardiovascular disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, pneumonia, stroke or cancer, "account for 73.4 percent of deaths, 52 percent of premature deaths and 76 percent of disdisability adjusted life years," revealed in the fourth National Risk Factor Survey.
Thus, the most common clinical manifestations associated with smoking have a strong impact on a country's economy and development. The public health costs account for $2 billion a year and, with all the mechanisms implemented around smoking, accounts for 1.2 per cent of Argentina's GDP. In addition, 63 per cent of the deficit in tax revenues through the tobacco sector is used to pay for health expenditure. In other words, 7.6 per cent of the country's total health expenditure goes to treating diseases caused by tobacco use. At no point will the account be closed face on. Smoking is still banned in the country despite all evidence supporting alternatives to smoking as a solution to health and economic problems. The anti-smoking campaign, based on smoking bans, is thoroughly conservative, leaving consumers to their own devices.
An 11-year ban on e-cigarettes
Argentina is the only country in the region not to have joined the World Health Organisation's (WHO) Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), which has 182 parties, because although it has been a signatory to the convention since 2003, it has not ratified it.
Nevertheless, the country has followed the main measures and recommendations of the experts who manage this international legal mechanism: banning advertising, consumption in public places, raising prices to discourage consumption, combating the illegal cigarette market and restricting or banning tobacco alternatives. That leaves changing the legal repertoire as the first strategy to tackle smoking, in addition to the conservative nature of the government's agenda.
The illegal cigarette trade exists in the daily lives of Argentines, especially those living in riverbed areas, who account for 12% of the country's total cigarette consumption. To this end, the exchequer spent about $82 million in 2017, with the total informal cigarette trade estimated at 22% in 2020.
But the illicit market in nicotine consumer products is not limited to traditional harmful cigarettes. Section 3226, 2011, not only has tobacco suffered over the past decade, but it has also made the alternative, e-cigarettes, a banned product. The sale and use of carburetors are prohibited in Argentina, and restrictions include the import of equipment, liquids or accessories. Although there is no active persecution of users, the controls aim to limit the affordability of vaping-related products as much as possible. As a result, Argentina's e-cigarette community stands in stark contrast to the more than 10 million smokers. A survey conducted by Argentina's National Ministry of Health in March 2020 found that of 29,224 people surveyed, 1.1% were dual users and 0.2% were exclusive consumers of e-cigarettes.
The same study clarified that teens "know" what e-cigarettes are: 41.8 percent are sure they are less harmful than smoking, 11.3 percent still believe they are as harmful as traditional cigarettes, 7.3 percent believe they are more harmful, and 39.7 percent are unsure of their risk level. The analysis included 1,453 opinions from students aged 13 to 15, of whom 18% (61.3% of those who answered) were active cigarette consumers, 7.1% were dual users, and only 3.7 only consumed e-cigarettes.
An organized social trade body
Clearly, Argentina's e-cigarette industry and trade have been complicated by busy policies that have slowed the development of the technology in the community. The most obvious mistake is to equate conventional cigarettes with e-cigarettes, leaving different sectors subject to bans that lack substance.
However, despite restrictions in place since 2011, ASOVAPE Argentina estimates that the e-cigarette market in the country has continued to grow since 2018, with an estimated market size of around $40 million that year. And $73 million in revenue by mid-2021.
"Argentines seem to be familiar with e-cigarettes, and even better, their general perception of their safety inflates the majority. This is why there is an urgent need for exclusivity and differentiation legislation, focusing on risk and harm reduction, as well as coherent controls to encourage smokers to change, why not stop consuming nicotine altogether in the future, "he commented. President, ASOVAPE Argentina.
ASOVAPE Argentina was founded in 2020 as a non-profit entity focused on community integration and bringing information about less harmful or dangerous alternatives to smokers. The association is made up of the e-cigarette users it represents in the field. "Anyone who supports this idea is welcome," Teme reminded us by phone, as his team includes Vice President Martin Scalese, Deputy Secretary Milton Klun, and General Secretary Aylen Van Isseldyk. ASOVAPE Argentina uses its social network as a platform to communicate with smokers, e-cigarette users and the public interested in harm reduction and e-cigarette choice. "You can easily contact us and we are ready to answer 'anything'," Concluded Teme. "In addition, evidence-based information about regulatory policies is available on the website and you can contact our team directly." Juan Facundo stated that in 2022 ASOVAPE will focus on the consolidation and steady progress of parliamentary affairs, seeking to change the way parliament treats the e-cigarette industry and ensuring that reducing the harm caused by smoking is a public interest issue that transcends political barriers.
In addition, the association intends to develop a local scientific plan with the participation of higher education entities capable of assessing the status of e-cigarettes. "Therefore, more important local research can be conducted to support the safety of e-cigarettes to generate collective and political awareness about tobacco harm reduction."

