Further research on Hawaii's e-cigarette flavor ban

Jun 21, 2022 Leave a message

In 2009, Hawaii's federal Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act banned the use of fruit and candy flavorings in combustible cigarettes, but allowed their use in e-cigarettes.

And in 2020, House Bill 2457 said the Reverse Youth Tobacco Epidemic of 2020 Act would ban the statewide sale of all flavored tobacco and e-cigarette products. The bill would also make it illegal for any retailer to inaccurately mark their products, mention any flavor on the label, or sell them in a way that makes them more attractive to teenagers. It has since been followed by other bills, most recently House Bill 1570.

The proposed changes include multiple authorizations required by state agencies for reporting and testing, which advocates say will make it difficult to enforce the ban. "We're frustrated that something so serious would be affected by these amendments," said Amanda Fernandez, director of policy and advocacy at the Hawaii Institute of Public Health. "It's a very common tactic for the tobacco industry to lobby for these types to be mixed in with other benign tobacco policies.

"Taste case" report

A new report titled "The Taste Case" by Dr. Konstantinos Farsalinos, a noted cardiologist and smoking cessation researcher, discusses the negative public health impact of e-cigarette flavor bans. The report stresses that the final taste bans are a ban that will only contribute to the growth of a massive black market and increased smoking rates, as they cause many e-cigarette consumers to return to smoking.

He explained that the risks of nicotine dependence and the risks associated with e-cigarette use cannot and should not be compared to the risks of smoking. Moreover, he stressed, it is the job of public health officials to weigh the pros and cons of any intervention and find the right balance. Farsalinos has long stressed that in the case of e-cigarettes, the benefits outweigh any adverse effects, and that this needs to be considered.

Based on these arguments, a new study published in Nicotine & Tobacco Research found that banning e-cigarette flavors would encourage e-cigarette consumers to return to smoking, while creating a huge black market for e-cigarettes. Of the 2,159 AMERICANS between the ages of 18 and 34 surveyed as part of the study, 33% would switch back to smoking if the taste wasn't available, according to study author Charles Gardner.

To that end, flavor restriction may be harmful rather than beneficial, the researchers concluded. "In addition, if Vape product sales were limited to tobacco flavor, 39.1% of users said they would likely continue using e-cigarettes, but 33.2% would switch to cigarettes. "E-cigarette users are equally likely to switch to cigarettes if sales of VAPE products are completely restricted," the study said.

The latest data

Supporting these findings, another recent study, published in JAMA Pediatrics, found that after San Francisco's flavor ban, teens in the city's high schools were more likely to smoke than those in U.S. school districts that did not have a taste ban. Before the ban, smoking rates in San Francisco were similar to those in many cities across the country.

"To understand this conceptually, consider young people's preferences for tobacco products," study author Abigail Friedman, assistant professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management at the Yale School of Public Health, said in a statement. "Among young people who use e-cigarettes, some may prefer the flavor of e-cigarettes to combustible tobacco products because of their rich flavor.

"For these people, as well as potential e-cigarette users with similar preferences, banning taste could remove the incentive to choose e-cigarettes over smoking," she added. "Therefore, some of them will respond to the taste ban by choosing to use combustible tobacco products rather than continuing to use e-cigarettes.