A U.S. court ordered the FDA to update e-cigarette PMTA information every 90 days starting April 29

Jun 21, 2022 Leave a message

Under the revised order by District Judge Paul Grimm of the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, the FOOD and Drug Administration will be required to provide premarket tobacco product application (PMTA) status reports every 90 days.

The first report is due April 29.

The revised order, signed on April 15, approved a motion by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and other plaintiffs asking the FDA to forecast the percentage of such products it expects to take action on by June 2022, and quarterly thereafter. Follow-up reports will also need clarification.

The order states that the applications covered are all applications for newly recognized tobacco products sold under brand names such as Juul, Vuse, NJoy, Logic, Blu, Smok, Suorin or Puff Bar.

In addition, several products of Vuse and Logic have been approved by the FDA in the Nielsen e-cigarette market and the participant or disposable e-cigarette market. In addition, the agency rejected Blu's application for Myblu products.

The decision by the e-cigarette industry is no surprise. Speaking at the firm's annual Electronic steam and Tobacco Law symposium Feb. 2-3, Azim Chowdhury, a partner at Keller and Heckman LLP, said the FDA appears to have agreed to the request for status reports on many of the remaining issues. The submission is being reviewed, adding that the update request requested by anti-vaping groups appears to be more extensive than the original request.

More than eight months have passed since the end of a 12-month continuous compliance policy for products submitted to PMTA on a timely basis, but the agency is still receiving about 88,000 reviews, including some of the e-cigarette products with the highest market share as measured by Nielsen.

Requiring status reports from the FDA can be controversial. Chowdhury said that if requiring status updates forced regulators to make PMTA decisions just to appease anti-vaping groups or politicians, it would not be appropriate to protect public health (APPH) or in the interest of the e-cigarette industry.

"These status reports can be used as a tool to force the FDA to take swift action (i.e., reject) applications." Chowdhury said. "Instead, we want the FDA to carefully review the science and take the time to determine whether specific products are APPH."

In November 2021, the anti-vaping group, whose lawsuit has an earlier deadline for filing a premarket Tobacco Product Application (PMTA), asked U.S. District Judge Paul Grimm to rehear the case. The plaintiffs asked him to require the FOOD and Drug Administration to regularly report on the filing status of the 10 best-selling steam brands ranked by Nielsen.