San Diego's City Council voted to pass an ordinance that would ban flavored e-cigarettes, cigarillos and menthol cigarettes in 2023.
The SAAFE bill, introduced by Assemblywoman Marni von Wilpert, bans flavored e-cigarettes and tobacco products, with the exception of premium flavored cigars, flavored leaf tobacco and water pipes.
Meanwhile, the Neighborhood Market Association cited data from San Francisco showing that banning flavored e-cigarettes would only encourage former smokers who have switched to e-cigarettes to start again. While the study was discredited by Jonathan Winickoff, director of pediatric research at the prestigious Tobacco Research and Treatment Center at Massachusetts General Hospital, another study reported similar findings.
San Francisco's flavor ban led to an increase in smoking rates
A second study, published in JAMA Pediatrics, found that after San Francisco's flavor ban, teens in the city's high schools were more likely to smoke than those in U.S. school districts that didn't have a flavor ban. Before the ban, San Francisco's smoking rates were similar to those of many cities across the country.
"To understand this conceptually, consider young people's preferences for tobacco products," study author Abigail Friedman, an assistant professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management at the Yale School of Public Health, said in a statement. "Among young people vaping, some may prefer ENDS to combustible products because of the taste."
Many e-cigarette users say they would return to smoking if their tastes were restricted.
A 2019 online survey of 240 Young Americans ages 18 to 29 asked participants about any changes in tobacco use behavior as a result of restrictions and projected these numbers. In the survey, which asked hypothetical questions about flavor bans and nicotine restrictions, about 47 percent said they would increase their use of traditional cigarettes.
About 22 percent said they would use fewer e-cigarettes and smoke more tobacco cigarettes if regulations limited device customizability, while 17 percent said they would use fewer e-cigarettes and smoke more traditional cigarettes if e-cigarette oil flavors were limited to tobacco and menthol.

