In 2009, the federal Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act banned the use of fruit and candy flavors in combustible cigarettes, but allowed them in e-cigarettes. And in 2020, House Bill 2457, called the Reverse Youth Tobacco Epidemic 2020 Act, would ban the statewide sale of all flavored tobacco and e-cigarette products.
The bill would also make it illegal for any retailer to inaccurately label its products and to market them in a way that makes them more attractive to teenagers by mentioning any flavor on the label. The bill was followed by several others, most recently House Bill 1570, which finally passed last week.
The bill's changes include multiple mandates from state agencies' reporting and testing requirements, which advocates say will only make the ban difficult to enforce. "We're disheartened that these amendments would harm something so serious," said Amanda Fernandez, director of policy and advocacy at the Hawaii Institute of Public Health. "It's a very common tactic for the tobacco industry to lobby for the inclusion of these types of poison pills in other good tobacco policies."
HB 1570 takes effect in 2023
In a speech on the House floor, representative Scot Matayoshi, the bill's sponsor, acknowledged HB 1570's shortcomings, adding that Hawaii is at "zero" in combating the local youth vaping epidemic. "We've been trying to pass any kind of flavored e-cigarette ban or restriction in this chamber for years," Matayoshi said. "Here we are... Will give our kids some hope that they won't have to be addicted to nicotine for the rest of their lives."
The ban, which will take effect in early 2023, will ban the sale of flavored e-cigarette products, menthol cigarettes and flavored cigars. The local e-cigarette industry, which is already regulated to prevent sales to minors, will be hit hard.
"99.9 percent of all products sold to adult consumers in our industry are flavored products that are legally age verified," said the CHIEF operating officer of Volcano, an e-cigarette chain with 16 locations across the state. "We're talking about hundreds of businesses, thousands of jobs."
Flavor bans don't work
E-cigarette owners say bans will only expand black markets for their products, a claim backed up by data from areas where such bans are in place. A 2020 deposition by the Massachusetts Tax Department's Illegal Tobacco Task Force discussed data on how e-cigarette users respond to such bans.Not surprisingly, the task force concluded that locally enforced flavor bans would lead to "increased smuggling activity and black-market sales."
"I'm concerned that burdening law enforcement and requiring them to enforce the spice ban will only create a major new black market, including interstate border smuggling and counterfeit tobacco," said Retiree Charles Giblin. Special agent in charge of the New Jersey Treasury Department's Office of Criminal Investigations.
"In the beginning, you're going to start to see an increase in the smuggling and illegal import of counterfeit flavored cigarettes through the Internet between Massachusetts and New Hampshire from countries like China and Paraguay. They would soar almost instantly, almost beyond belief, "he said. The reality is that it is.

