On Friday, the FDA submitted the first PMTA review status report authorized by U.S. District Court Judge Paul Grimm. The report was originally due on April 29, but the FDA requested a two-week extension.
The agency estimates that it will not complete its review of premarket tobacco applications (PMTAS) for the most popular e-cigarette products for more than a year from now, nearly three years after the September 9, 2020 PMTA submission deadline. If progress reports were report cards, the FDA would get an F by anyone's standards.
Judge Grimm ordered FDA to report on the progress of its review of submitted PMTas, the most popular e-cigarette product brands sold in the convenience store/gas station vape market segment. The reports will be submitted to the court every 90 days in the form of court documents, with the next report due by July 29.
Judge Grimm ordered the agency to estimate when PMTA will be completed for "products marketed under the Juul, Vuse, NJoy, Logic, Blu, Smok, Suorin or Puff Bar brands," as well as any other products with a market share of 2 percent or more Review the market share measured in Nielsen's published market reports.
Did we learn anything new in the progress report?
The FDA report itself is anticlimactic, providing no details on possible decision dates for individual products or brands. The FDA's submission to the judge is merely an estimate of the date by which the agency will make a decision on some percentage of all applications still under review.
Without mentioning the manufacturer or the product name, the FDA noted that only one product in addition to the designated brand meets the standard, and a total of 240 PMTAS that meet the judge's requirements remain under review. The Agency estimates that it will complete its review of the following
By June 30, 2022, 51% of applications will be covered
By September 30, 2022, 52% of applications will be covered
By December 31, 2022, 56 percent of covered applications
By March 31, 2023, 56 percent of applications are covered
By June 30, 2023, 100 percent of applications are covered
Judge Grimm's status reporting order granted the plaintiffs' motion in a lawsuit filed last fall by the American Academy of Pediatrics and others against the FDA, asking the judge to revise his original decision, which set a new deadline for PMTA submissions. The revised order requires the FDA to "provide periodic status reports to the courts" estimating when the agency will complete PMTA reviews of the most popular e-cigarette products.

