The latest episode of Oxford University and the Cochrane podcast "Let's Talk About e-cigarettes" demonstrates the power of e-cigarettes as a harm-reduction tool, especially in vulnerable populations.
"Let's Talk E-Cigarettes" is a popular science podcast about the latest research on these devices. The speakers are two Oxford University researchers who are members of the Cochrane Panel on Tobacco Addiction: Jamie Hartmann-Boyce and Nicola Lindson. The publication, funded by Cancer Research UK, is available on Spotify and iTunes or on the Cochrane and Oxford University websites.
The podcast always begins with an Irish-sounding song that makes clear the big problem with e-cigarettes: doubts about their safety. It points to the possibility of addressing the problem with reliable information, such as the Cochrane review, in which "all facts have been verified at least twice". Similarly, the hosts explained that each episode was based on their investigative work, in which they scoured the scientific literature on e-cigarettes to find new relevant studies.
The potential of e-cigarettes
The first episode of 2022, which aired on 28 January, started with a reference to a study led by Dr Pasquali Carpineto of the University of Catania and published in the journal Nicotine and Tobacco Research. This aims to "investigate the feasibility of e-cigarettes changing smoking behavior in patients with schizophrenia spectrum disorder."
The study involved 40 people who did not want to quit or cut down on smoking, some of whom formed a research group whose members were given a Juul device that supplied cartridgescontaining 5% nicotine for 12 weeks. At the last follow-up at week 24, they found that 57.5 percent of the group had reduced cigarette consumption by 50 percent or more, while 35 percent had quit smoking completely. At the end of the study, all participants were still using e-cigarettes.
The power to reduce damage
After the introduction, the presenter turns to the episode's main theme, which is that Dr Sharon Cox, a researcher at the Department of Behavioural and Health Sciences at University College London, works on tobacco-related health inequalities and how e-cigarettes can help reduce them.
Cox explained that he introduced himself to e-cigarettes through contact harm reduction while working with homeless people. The experience made him wonder why harm reduction, if applied to areas such as drug, alcohol or sexual behaviour, was not followed in the use of tobacco. When he started to put the idea into practice, he realized how much it could help people physically, emotionally and spiritually. Not just the people receiving treatment, but even the support staff.
Dr Cox described how they realised e-cigarettes were highly accepted, started a dialogue with vulnerable groups, offered them opportunities to improve their quality of life and even delivered a message of care to people who had traditionally been marginalised. The bond is so strong that even support center workers use e-cigarettes originally offered to patients to quit smoking.
In his words, "What harm reduction can do is get people into treatment or get them interested in changing their behavior without having to think about quitting smoking, which could be a big step for some of them." In this sense, e-cigarettes have proven to be a harm-reduction tool with great potential to eventually achieve smoking cessation, even in extremely vulnerable populations, so it's logical to take the initiative on a larger scale.
Mass e-cigarette use
The UK's National Institute for Health Research believes e-cigarettes have been shown to help people change their behaviour and eventually quit smoking. For that reason, it approved a larger study, a cohort randomized controlled trial at 32 care centers.
As Dr. Cox explains, the study will only begin selecting centers in September 2021 and will begin recruiting participants in February 2022. The trial will last three years, so we'll have to wait a while to find out. However, some important points can already be discussed.
First, there is the choice of devices, and there should be an opinion from the people who use them.In relation to them, the basic factors mentioned were price, ease of loading them and taste (tobacco, fruit or menthol being offered). Similarly, training on tobacco use and how to help people quit smoking, as well as training on the use and choice of e-cigarettes (how to load them, how to replenish them, to whom and what type), also plays a central role. Learning. It's most convenient for each person.
As Dr Cox explains, the hope is to create a complete and reliable source of information from the whole process for those who want to access the harm reduction associated with smoking.
Heath is a right
One of the key questions Dr Cox answers is why tobacco use does not receive enough attention or support to tackle it when it comes to vulnerable groups. The main reason is that, at least in this often very high-risk population, tobacco use is not seen as a priority.
Nonetheless, Cox insists there is a need to consider the best possible quality of life as a human right, which means providing the necessary help to quit smoking. In fact, it shows the widespread neglect of health-related issues by vulnerable groups and the need to treat them as a right. In this sense, harm reduction is not only a great public health tool; It's also a powerful speech that can help people improve their health by making them feel like they've done so without having to endure the pain of having to give up a habit.

