Public health ethics emphasizes that the achievement of public health goals should "minimize violations of individual rights and freedoms". Whether a smoker decides to quit smoking or switch to e-cigarettes, we should respect that.
Electronic cigarettes are far less harmful than cigarettes and should be used as a harm reduction strategy, according to a new paper published by three researchers at the University of Pittsburgh.
E-cigarettes are far less harmful than cigarettes
The ethics of Tobacco harm Reduction: An Analysis of e-cigarette Usability from the Perspectives of Utilitarianism, Bioethics, and Public Health Ethics
"E-cigarette Availability" is a group intervention to encourage smokers to switch to e-cigarettes. It has two implications: to make it clear to smokers that e-cigarettes are less harmful than cigarettes, and to make sure they have easy access to e-cigarettes.
The authors point out that "e-cigarette availability" is supported by two ethical frameworks: public health ethics and biomedical ethics. "E-cigarette availability" helps smokers reduce health risks and hazards, and enables smokers to make their own health decisions, in line with the principles of respect for individual rights and autonomy, and promotes social equity and justice. At the same time, achieving public health goals with "e-cigarette availability" is less restrictive than traditional tobacco control approaches.
"The core of public health practice is to minimise the impact of bad behaviour on public health, not to eliminate it entirely."
"Groups of concern do not conflict with respect for individual rights," the authors note in their paper. "[public health] officials and physicians should encourage smokers to switch to e-cigarettes and reduce violations of smokers' individual rights and freedoms."
"Whether a smoker decides to quit smoking or switch to e-cigarettes, we should respect that."
The framework of biomedical ethics had proposed four principles, namely respect for autonomy, kindness (to increase patient welfare), non-malevolence (to avoid harm to patients) and justice. Switching to e-cigarettes, which are far less harmful than cigarettes, allows smokers to avoid the harm caused by traditional tobacco and is therefore in line with the principle of kindness and non-malice.
More importantly, it also fully meets the ethical need to respect the principle of autonomy. Respecting autonomy means respecting individuals' right to make informed decisions according to their own wishes.
Providing e-cigarette products and e-cigarette harm reduction information to smokers can ensure that smokers can make choices based on their own values and preferences without any coercion or deception, which is a reflection of respecting the rights of smokers.
The ethical framework for public health has always emphasized that achieving public health goals should minimize violations of individual rights and freedoms.
Even smokers who start to quit late in life have the right and freedom to pursue harm reduction. Their rights and interests also need to be protected. "Everyone has the right to pursue their own definition of happiness and whether a smoker decides to quit smoking or switch to e-cigarettes, we should respect that." "Says Rebecca Thomas of the University of Pittsburgh, one of the paper's authors.
"Withholding and misrepresenting information about e-cigarettes undermines public health agencies' credibility."
Since the individual rights of smokers should be respected, it is important to provide accurate e-cigarette information to ensure that smokers make informed decisions. "They [e-cigarette opponents] may say it's safer to 'make the public overestimate the risks of vaping', but withholding and misrepresenting information about vaping undermines public health authorities' credibility.
"Once credibility is lost, the public will question or even ignore other risk information, causing major public health hazards." Take the case of lung disease in the United States reported last year, when studies confirmed that it was caused by the use of black-market fumes illegally laced with THC, a highly concentrated chemical derived from industrial marijuana, and was not related to regular e-cigarettes.
The CDC ignored the findings and blamed regular e-cigarettes until march this year. The authors argue that the practice, which appears to protect consumers, does more harm than good: "Not only does it drive smokers who have already switched to e-cigarettes back to smoking, but it does not protect people from the real culprit, black-market THC products."
The ethical framework of public health states that achieving public health goals requires the use of the least restrictive interventions. In terms of tobacco harm reduction targets, providing smokers with e-cigarettes is less restrictive than banning e-cigarettes and all tobacco products, and therefore meets their ethical needs.
In addition, providing smokers with e-cigarette products and e-cigarette harm reduction information can also provide vulnerable groups with cheaper harm reduction programmes, reduce social health disparities and promote social justice.
With tobacco responsible for more than 8 million deaths a year, according to the World Health Organization, it is imperative to reduce the damage. "There is overwhelming evidence that e-cigarettes are much less harmful than cigarettes, and both public health ethical frameworks and biomedical ethical frameworks demonstrate that e-cigarette availability is ethical and beneficial, so smokers should be encouraged to switch to e-cigarettes." The paper points out.

