TPD Review: Scientific committee submits report on e-cigarettes

Jun 22, 2022 Leave a message

A meta-analysis of studies on e-cigarettes

It is no secret that the Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) is coming under review. This is the European legislative framework surrounding the sale, manufacturing, advertising and more generally related to tobacco (and e-cigarette) products, and a few days ago the Scientific Committee on Health, Environment and Emerging Risks (SCHEER) submitted a proposal on being commissioned by the European Commission (EC). The report could be used to determine future e-cigarette legislation in the European Union.

The authors said they looked at all the scientific literature on e-cigarette products published between January 2015 and April 2019, as well as reports from "other organizations" on the subject.

essence

The report begins by noting that most studies on the subject use US data. While the authors note that the US market can be "very different" from Europe's, they note that applying the US situation to Europe cannot be ruled out.

The paper says there is "strong evidence" that the flavors used attract adults and young people to use e-cigarettes. It added that they were responsible for a "reduced perceived risk" of e-cigarette use among minors.

Taste is obviously also the main reason young people want to try e-cigarettes, but it's also one of the reasons adults use e-cigarette devices.

Use e-cigarettes to quit smoking

In terms of quitting smoking, SCHEER noted that the number of Smokers in Europe who have tried to quit without the support of a health professional has increased in recent years, from 70.3% in 2012 to 74.8% in 2017.

The drop coincided with an increase in the number of people trying e-cigarettes as a way to quit smoking, rising from 3.7 percent to 9.7 percent over the same period.

The number of smokers who tried to quit using drugs and smoking cessation services fell from 14.6% to 11.1% and from 7.5% to 5%, respectively.

However, the committee notes that attempts to quit smoking through the use of e-cigarettes vary from country to country. For example, only 5% of smokers in Spain have tried it, compared with 51.6% in the UK.

It also notes that there is some evidence that e-cigarettes can help people quit smoking, but this is limited because of the small number of studies on the topic.

The health effects of e-cigarettes

According to the report, the health effects of e-cigarettes are unclear, particularly because of a lack of evidence of long-term use. However, the authors point out that the World Health Organisation (WHO) says that while e-cigarettes "may be less harmful than smoking", they are still "a health hazard".

With regard to nicotine poisoning caused by inhaling e-liquids, particularly in young children, and the risk of e-cigarette explosion, the Committee considers that such risks are very serious. However, they are also very rare.

It also notes growing evidence that using e-cigarette products can harm cardiovascular health. However, the authors say more research is needed on the topic.

The Committee's conclusions on health risks:

The risk of local irritation during atomization is considered to be moderate.

The risk of harm from toxic chemicals such as aldehydes, formaldehyde, acrolein and diacetyl is serious for heavy users and cannot be ruled out for light or moderate users.

The risk of poisoning from ingestion and explosion is high but rare.

The risks to the heart are thought to be high, especially because of the effects of nicotine on the body (increased blood pressure and heart rate).

The risk to the pulmonary system is considered low to moderate, especially because of the presence of formaldehyde and acetaldehyde. However, there is too little evidence of human relevance to draw any conclusions.

The risk of heavy metals is considered low.

At present, there is no specific data to suggest that the flavoring agents used in Europe cause any problems. However, they do help increase the appeal of e-cigarette products.

The authors also note that the high carbonyl levels detected in some studies may be directly related to poor e-cigarette habits, such as dry smoking.

Secondhand smoke

When it comes to the risk of second-hand smoke, the authors note that the risk is currently considered low, mainly because of a lack of data.

They show that the risk of stimulation is considered moderate, while the cardiovascular risk and cancer risk range from low to moderate.

Vaping among young people

Teen e-cigarette users in Europe have reportedly increased in recent years, from 7.2 percent in 2012 to 14.6 percent in 2017.

However, e-cigarettes have also been shown to be more common among adolescents and young adults who already smoke or have smoked.

SCHEER noted that for many young people, e-cigarettes are considered "cool," especially when used with tobacco shells.

However, the authors point out that these figures are from the US, where products on the market may differ from those sold in Europe

conclusion

The report is beyond comprehension.

When you read it, the authors seem very pragmatic and relatively cautious about their conclusions.

However, in the summary at the beginning of the document, they only seem to point to negative data collected during the study.

The report's conclusions on the health effects of e-cigarettes:

There is moderate evidence that e-cigarettes cause local irritation of the respiratory organs in the most severe cases, and low to moderate e-cigarettes cannot be ruled out.

There is strong evidence that e-cigarettes are risky to the cardiovascular system in the long term.

There is weak to moderate evidence that e-cigarettes are harmful to the lung system.

There is no evidence that heavy metals pose a risk to e-cigarettes.

There is strong evidence of a risk of nicotine poisoning (through ingestion).

There is strong evidence that e-cigarette products pose an explosion risk. However, poisonings and explosions are rare.

There is no evidence that spices used in Europe are harmful.

About passive e-cigarettes:

In terms of local irritation, the risk of e-cigarettes to people nearby is considered moderate.

Their cardiovascular and pulmonary risks are considered low to moderate.

About gateway theory:

There is strong evidence that e-cigarettes are a route to smoking.

There is strong evidence that the nicotine in e-cigarette oils can be addictive, and the taste they contain has an impact on the attractiveness of e-cigarettes.

On whether e-cigarettes can help people quit smoking:

There is weak evidence that e-cigarettes can help people quit smoking.

There is weak to moderate evidence that using e-cigarettes can reduce tobacco consumption.

In conclusion, e-cigarettes are not helpful for people to quit smoking, their taste attracts young people to take e-cigarettes, and using e-cigarettes is harmful to your health.

None of this bodes well for the next revision of TPD.