Tobacco harm reduction advocates condemn the anti-e-cigarette campaign

Jun 21, 2022 Leave a message

"By stirring up anti-vaping hysteria, the Asthma and Breathing Foundation of New Zealand will only drive more underage smokers back into smoking and jeopardise the country's decade-long smoke-free 2025 ambition," said Nancy Loucas, executive coordinator of the Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Alliance.

Reduction Advocate (CAPHRA) Loucas' comments follow the launch of a video series called "Spotlight on Vaping" by the Asthma and Breathing Foundation (ARFNZ). The campaign claims New Zealand is experiencing an "epidemic" of e-cigarette use among young people. Along with the New Zealand Association of Secondary School Principals (SPANZ), it also claims that more than a quarter of students have vaped in the past week.

"These sensational numbers don't take into account that if 26 percent of students actually vaped e-cigarettes in the past week, then many will just try it, and second, almost all will smoke lethal cigarettes a generation ago," Lucas said.

While smoking-related illnesses kill about 5,000 New Zealanders each year, vaping has not been reported to have caused a single death in the country, CAPHRA said. In fact, e-cigarettes are widely seen as a positive contribution to the decline in smoking rates in New Zealand. Overall daily smoking rates among adults have fallen from 18 per cent in 2006/07 to 9.4 per cent in 2020-2021.

"What ARFNZ did not mention was that their selective reference to ASH's 10th Year Snapshot survey in 2021 confirmed that e-cigarettes did not appeal to non-smokers. Only 3 percent of daily e-cigarette users in the survey had never smoked. What's more, while many people may try it, few become regular e-cigarette users, especially non-smoking students, "she said.

Lucas said that while ARFNZ made headlines with claims of a "youth vaping epidemic," researchers at the University of Auckland came to a different conclusion in 2020: "Our results do not support the notion of a so-called e-cigarette epidemic or a large young population in New Zealand. Reliance on e-cigarettes, "the researchers wrote." While no one wants young people to use e-cigarettes, we are not seeing the 'epidemic' that ARFNZ would have the public believe.