"Tobacco harm reduction (THR) may be particularly beneficial as it allows smokers to switch to less harmful alternatives during the process of quitting completely," said Dr Arifin Fi. "Official statistics show that there is little evidence that existing tobacco control strategies are working, as the willingness of most smokers to quit is low."
After attending the recent Virtual Global Forum on Tobacco and Nicotine (GTNF) 2021, Fi explained that Malaysia needs to find innovative solutions to manage the high smoking rate there. "This is where tobacco harm reduction (THR) is particularly beneficial, as it allows smokers to switch to less harmful alternatives during the process of quitting completely," he said.
A recent survey showed that 80 percent of Malaysians were in favor of having the local e-cigarette industry regulated by the authorities. In early 2021, the Malaysian E-Cigarette Chamber of Commerce (MVCC) called on the Malaysian government to come up with appropriate regulations on nicotine-containing e-liquids. Among other things, the move will have a positive impact on the local economy by creating more jobs and attracting foreign direct investment (FDI), he said.
"As a result of the survey, there are more than 3,300 businesses directly associated with the e-cigarette industry, employing more than 15,000 people," MVCC said when launching its report on the E-cigarette industry in Malaysia.
MVCC president Syed Azaudin Syed Ahmad said the results of the report showed that the sector was a viable and growing industry in Malaysia and had fostered the growth of local entrepreneurs. "In addition, the Malaysian e-cigarette industry now has a mature ecosystem of manufacturers, importers and retailers, as well as a growing distribution and logistics network," he said.
The public needs sensible e-cigarette regulations
A recent poll suggests the public feels the same way. The poll entitled "Malaysian Insights and Views on Vape" was commissioned by Vape Industry Advocacy Malaysia (MVIA) and conducted by market research firm Green Zebras. The aggregated responses showed that 76% of respondents agreed that Malaysia's economy would benefit from regulated products.
In addition, 87 percent agreed with a tax on e-cigarettes, and 74 percent said the government could use the revenue to fund important areas such as education and the economy. "Recent reports by local industry groups have confirmed that the e-cigarette industry has great potential to contribute to the Malaysian economy, with the ability to create jobs, grow existing businesses and smes (small and medium enterprises) within the industry, and attract investment," MVIA said President Rizani Zakaria.
E-cigarettes will soon be banned
Meanwhile, Malaysian Health Minister Khairy Jamaluddin recently announced a ban on the sale of cigarettes and safer nicotine replacement products to people born in 2005 or later. The plan was unveiled at the 150th executive Board meeting of the World Health Organisation (WHO), and Jamaluddin said he hoped the legislation would be completed this year and would bring "the end of smoking for a generation".
In response to this statement, numerous international public health experts have written to Prime Minister Ismail Sabri Yakob warning him that such measures will only end up creating a huge black market and fuel the illegal trade in products.
In the letter, academics and tobacco harm reduction experts David Abrams, Clive Bates, Ray Niaura and David Sweanor say the prohibitionist approach could have unintended consequences. "We want the government to consider the limitations of the ban and the possible unintended consequences. We would like ministers to consider alternative approaches to regulation based on MPOWER and risk ratios to reduce tobacco harm."

