According to BusinessTech, the Free Market Foundation is concerned that the South African government's plans to regulate e-cigarette products will prompt more people to return to traditional combustible cigarettes and buy them on the black market.
"The South African government believes e-cigarettes and vaping products are harmful and need to be regulated," the Free Market Foundation said. "However, e-cigarettes and e-cigarette innovations are tobacco harm reduction products designed to mitigate the adverse health effects associated with combustible tobacco products."
"The total excise tax on nicotine and non-nicotine solutions, e-cigarettes and e-cigarettes will range from ZAR33.30 [$2.28] to ZAR346. As a result, poor communities with tobacco-related diseases will have more incentive to continue smoking than choosing healthier alternatives."
"In reality, smokers may simply choose illegal products, which are cheaper and account for 42 percent of the informal cigarette market. In addition, illegal goods are more harmful because they do not follow production standards." The illicit cigarette market in South Africa grew substantially during the temporary ban, but has yet to shrink to pre-embargo levels.
"A proposal by the National Treasury to tax e-cigarette solutions that do not contain tobacco or nicotine may be questioned by some stakeholders as it does not necessarily support the government's stated policy intent to reduce consumption of tobacco products," said Weber Winzel, representing a law firm. "It could also stimulate the illegal trade in e-cigarettes, as happened in the tobacco industry."
If passed, the proposed tax would take effect on January 1, 2023.

