As part of its global tobacco harm reduction project, Knowledge Action Change (KAC) has released the latest in a series of newsletters. The publication is entitled: "What is Tobacco Harm Reduction?" The principles, history and evidence of this important public health strategy are described in detail.
For the 1.1 billion people around the world who smoke combustible cigarettes, reducing tobacco harm is one way to potentially save lives. Like other forms of harm reduction, it recognises that not all smokers can simply quit. People smoke for nicotine, but nicotine by itself does not cause smoking-related deaths and illnesses -- it is the chemical in tobacco smoke inhaled. Eliminating burning reduces the risk. For those who cannot or do not want to quit nicotine, tobacco harm reduction offers the opportunity to switch to safer nicotine products, including nicotine e-cigarettes, smokeless nicotine bags, Swedish snuff, many American smokeless tobacco and heated tobacco products.
Many of these products have only been developed in the past 10 to 15 years, but they are proving increasingly popular. A GSTHR study released in March estimated there would be 82 million e-cigarette users worldwide in 2021.
This is a 20% increase over the 2020 figure (68 million) and means 112 million people worldwide are using safer nicotine products. A striking example of tobacco harm reduction potential can be found in Scandinavia. As Swedish men switched from smoking to snuff, Sweden now has the lowest incidence of tobacco-related diseases in Europe, while in Norway, 12% of women aged 16-24 use snuff daily, while only 1% smoke.
In the UK, according to KAC, tobacco harm reduction programmes can play a key role in the government's efforts to achieve smoke-free status (defined as prevalence of less than 5% of the population) by 2030. The popularity of e-cigarettes has been accompanied by a rapid decline in smoking.
E-cigarettes are the most popular way to quit smoking, with 3.6 million people using them in the UK, 2.4 million of whom have given up combustible cigarettes altogether. But tobacco remains the single biggest cause of preventable death in England, with almost 75,000 smokers dying in 2019 and figures showing that nearly one in 10 pregnant women smokes at birth.
"Quitting smoking is possible -- but the broadest range of harm-reduction products, from nicotine e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products to non-tobacco nicotine bags and Swedish snuff, should be available, accessible, appropriate and affordable to all."
KAC Director Gerry Stimson
It is vital that the UK government continues to reduce smoking rates if it is to tackle the health disparities caused by smoking, which currently place a disproportionate burden on the most vulnerable families and communities. Smoking rates vary widely across the country - in Blackpool, for example, around one in five people smoke (19.8 per cent), while in Richmond on-Thames, around 20 smoke (6 per cent). People with drug and alcohol problems (56 per cent of those receiving treatment smoke), homeless people (77 per cent of whom smoke in England) and people with mental health problems (26.8 per cent of whom smoke in England).
But according to KAC, adopting tobacco harm reduction will not only help the UK deal with the effects of smoking. It has enormous potential as a global public health solution. Smoking kills 7.7 million people a year, and current tobacco control measures are not reducing smoking-related deaths and illness fast enough.
The GSTHR fact sheet, translated into Spanish, Russian, Mandarin, French, Portuguese, Indonesian, Swahili, Japanese, German, Polish, Hindi and Arabic, aims to start a dialogue in countries around the world that are not yet aware of harm reduction.
"Ending smoking is possible - but the broadest range of harm reduction products, from nicotine-cigarettes and heated tobacco products to non-tobacco nicotine bags and Swedish snuff, should be available, accessible, appropriate and affordable," said Gerry Stimson, KAC director and emeritus professor at Imperial College London.
"Strong government support is also needed to ensure access to services for marginalized and vulnerable people. The benefits will be clear in terms of saving lives and protecting communities. Crucially, tobacco harm reduction is a very low-cost but effective strategy - a rare example of a health intervention that does not require significant government spending because consumers bear the cost. Quitting is possible - reducing tobacco harm is key."

