Researchers have exposed the poor quality of highly cited research on e-cigarettes

Jun 21, 2022 Leave a message

Why is there an urgent need to improve the quality of e-cigarette and e-cigarette research?

Research on the safety and effectiveness of e-cigarettes has been controversial for more than a decade. Both sides are carefully painted. Professional e-cigarette users often cite researchers who report that e-cigarettes are safer than smoking and can help people quit. Anti-vaping advocates cite studies that dispute these results.

So who's right?

An illuminating investigation

Using Google's algorithm, an international team of researchers examined 24 e-cigarette studies published in scientific journals that were "widely read and cited in other literature and policy debates." Almost all were conducted in the United States, and topics included smoking initiation, breathing problems, and reducing and quitting. The overwhelming majority's findings seem to contradict the use of e-cigarettes as a harm-reduction tool.

The researchers included Dr. Cother Hajat of the University of the United Arab Emirates and Dr. Riccardo Polosa, founder of the Center of Excellence for Accelerated Injury Reduction (CoEHAR) at the University of Catania, Italy, They just published their paper "Analyzing Common Methodological Flaws in the most cited epidemiological studies of e-cigarettes."

They were surprised that almost all of the studies were methodologically flawed. They lacked clear assumptions, used inadequate methods, did not collect data relevant to study objectives, or did not correct for obvious confounding factors.

"I was surprised that such a low-quality study had made it past editorial scrutiny in a reputable scientific journal."

The researchers were left speechless, and what they found was irrefutable evidence of junk science.

"I was surprised that such a low-quality study had made it through editorial review in a reputable scientific journal," Dr. Polosa said. "The credibility of tobacco control scientists and their research is threatened."

Recurring failures

Among other things, the researchers discredited studies that claimed to demonstrate the so-called "portal effect," which has been widely used to scare the public into believing that smoking nicotine leads to the use of combustible tobacco. "The studies we reviewed lacked robust research methods to reliably establish cause-and-effect relationships or determine gateway effects," the authors wrote.

This is not the first time the so-called gateway effect has been deployed in a drug scare. For nearly a century, researchers claimed marijuana was the route to "harder" drugs. It was a lie all along.

"In our article, we provide practical recommendations that could greatly improve the quality and rigor of future research in the field of tobacco harm reduction," explains Dr Hajat.

The recommendations include:

1. Recognize the impact of smoking history on health (critical when the vast majority of e-cigarette users are former smokers);

2. Detail the habit and history of vaping (and smoking) in terms of duration, quantity and frequency;

3. Ensure the allocation and randomization of study participants to avoid selection bias;

4. Ensure that implications and conclusions do not imply causality unless causality has been established;

5. Honestly and transparently discuss biases, limitations and alternative explanations, as well as the possible implications of the findings.

E-cigarette research needs to change

The very fact that these basic recommendations have to be made says a lot about the state of e-cigarette research and how stubborn some researchers are in distorting the evidence, scientists say.

Other scientists are right to point out big flaws in e-cigarette research. In one of the most egregious examples, the Journal of the American Heart Association retracted its 2020 article "Adult e-cigarette use and Myocardial infarction in the Tobacco and Health Population Assessment of the United States." Its authors, Dr Dharma Bhatta and Stanton Glantz, claim e-cigarette use is linked to an increased risk of heart attack.

The e-cigarette research industry urgently needs an impartial investigation. Over 1 billion smokers, of whom 8 million die each year from smoking-related causes, deserve research to honestly examine and explain safer nicotine alternatives.