New research: No conclusive evidence that e-cigarette use may lead young people to take up smoking

May 30, 2022 Leave a message

April 24 - The evidence that e-cigarette use may lead young people to smoke isn't as strong as it seems, according to an analysis that combined 17 studies to examine whether e-cigarette use is linked to subsequent smoking, according to the Vapingpost.

The study, carried out by researchers from the Alcohol and Tobacco Research Group (TARG) at the University of Bristol, with support from the MRC Integrated Epidemiology Unit (IEU) in Bristol and the NIHR Bristol Biomedical Research Centre (BRC), found that young e-cigarette users who do not smoke are almost five times more likely to smoke than the general population.

But the findings do not provide hard evidence for a possible "portal effect" or atomization theory that causes smoking. "Policy makers have used the results of studies, including the one we conducted in this study, to support strict regulation of e-cigarettes, including restrictions on flavors or even outright bans, but the evidence suggests that e-cigarette use may be causing young people to smoke less strongly than it seems." Jasmine Khouja, TARG doctoral student in the School of Psychological Sciences.

In their analysis, the team found a number of problems related to the study, leading them to conclude that smoking was not appropriate for e-cigarette use. While the association between e-cigarette use by non-smokers and subsequent smoking appears to be strong, the available evidence is unreliable because the data were collected through self-reported measures of smoking history rather than biochemical validation.

In addition, none of the studies included negative controls that would show whether the association was causal. For this reason, tobacco harm reduction experts have long pointed out that the link between cigarettes and e-cigarettes cannot be considered causal, because personality factors also need to be taken into account. Young people tend to experiment more than other age groups. Also, those who tend to be experimental personality types may dabble in a variety of substances, including e-cigarettes and regular cigarettes.

"Much of the evidence does not take into account nicotine levels in e-cigarettes used by non-smokers, meaning it is difficult to draw conclusions about whether nicotine is the mechanism responsible for this association," the researchers added. They concluded that future studies should address the issues already highlighted and analyze the correlation between e-cigarettes and smoking by using more advanced tests.