Regulation of safer nicotine consumption products could prevent thousands of deaths each year while boosting socio-economic development in Latin America. However, several countries in the region continue to oppose this view, opting for prohibitionism for more than a decade, failing to gain significant fiscal and tax revenues and, more seriously, losing access to health care relevant to these consumers. Products.
In many cities in the region, it is easy to find copies of adulterated products or imported liquids in any market or exhibition, which poses a direct risk to the health of consumers and a minor public health problem. In fact, millions of consumers in most South American countries continue to use unregulated e-cigarette products without any quality control
Regulatory initiatives in the region can ensure the protection of the health of the growing number of e-cigarette users by providing legal products that meet safety and quality standards to minimize or eliminate problems associated with the illicit market while helping to overcome the economic crisis.
In this series, the situation of e-cigarettes in several Latin American countries will be analyzed in order to understand their current and future prospects from representatives of civil society organizations.
Panama: Not just for the next COP10
In recent years, Panama has been one of the world Health Organization's (WHO) and Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) favorite countries to report on its record reduction of tobacco consumption in the 21st century. In 2000, about 17 percent of Panamanians used tobacco, while in 2021 and since 2019, only 6.3 percent of the population declared themselves consumers.
Such a large reduction is due to the strict financial control regime implemented since the beginning of the century. However, the implementation of Law No. 13 on January 24, 2008, which made tobacco taxes stricter and more stringent, marked a turning point for panama's tobacco industry. Inconveniently, the law eventually led to the creation of new irregular markets, resulting in lost tax revenues and real-life consumption statistics errors.
Unfortunately, Panama has become a major hub for the trade, transportation and distribution of Tobacco products in China and has taken over the illicit trade throughout the African continent and the Caribbean. The freeports of Colon are Overseas United Inc., Finta Inc. Or operations centers for Asian tobacco companies such as Kinea International SA, which have the same partners and operate under the law with few restrictions.
China National Tobacco corporation, the world's biggest tobacco company, has opted for an old strategy that worked in the 1990s for today's giants Philip Morris International (PMI) and British American Tobacco (BAT) : using informal markets to flood its trade. Products also force countries into regulated markets. Colombia, Ecuador and Belize are some of the countries that have fallen victim to smuggling (apart from their lax regulations failing to stem irregular flows, corruption in these governments is also prominent).
In 2019, Panama became the continent's largest consumer of smuggled cigarettes, reaching 750 million cigarettes, or 72.5% of the national market. For that reason, the Treasury stopped collecting more than $100 million in taxes.
Although the data are not updated, about 5.2% of deaths in Panama each year are attributed to tobacco use. According to the Global Tobacco Harm Reduction website, the prevalence of tobacco use is recorded at 5.7 per cent, with 5.9 per cent of deaths attributed to consumption by the male public, compared with 3.4 per cent for women.
The Panama case raises many questions about the effectiveness of traditional tobacco control strategies: extreme inspections and almost ineffective customs controls do not allow for the collection of real data on consumption because they are based on sales per cigarette, leading to inaccurate data in economies where consumption of the product is not under the radar of the state.
In Panama, tobacco-consumption-related deaths account for nearly 6 per cent of total deaths each year, with men being the biggest victims because, as we have seen, they die twice as many as women. As one of the biggest legal barriers to nicotine consumption in the region, the government has left leeway only for oral tobacco and reduced nicotine therapies such as patches, gums and drug sprays.
The state of the e-cigarette industry
E-cigarettes are virtually nonexistent in daily life in Panama. It is a completely "secret" market, as both consumers and sellers try to go unnoticed to avoid severe sanctions. "Vaping as a culture in this country has not been cemented. Panama is a hybrid of many other countries' ideologies, but e-cigarettes are completely underground; The person who vapes does it because he knows it, "says Tomas Sanchez, president of panama's Association for Smoking Harm Reduction (ARDTP).
For this reason, it is difficult to retrieve data on the number of e-cigarette users in Panama, but it is presumed that no more than 0.8% of the population are active e-cigarette consumers. "I met several people who didn't even know what 60 milliliters of vaping was, they didn't know the difference between a free base or a salt, they didn't know what a cotton ball was or a resistor," Sanchez recalls.In this case, the market and the e-cigarette culture suffer because the entry of "copy" products is ready to go at a much lower cost and directly threatens the health of consumers.
In any case, the e-cigarette community isn't very big, and in Sanchez's view, another factor that could influence that is the black market for cigarettes, which have a very low price. As a result, the e-cigarette industry is developing in a gray market, as the vast majority of e-cigarette goods that are illegal in Panama enter through the Colon free port, which has an exemption for the illegal introduction of e-vaping-related products.
Alhough Panamanians have been heavily sanctioned for selling e-cigarette products, it is common to find stores and distributors for a variety of goods on social networks. However, monitoring and blocking of these accounts is so pervasive that it is impossible to contact stores directly or through word of mouth to find them. Similarly, it's not uncommon to find pirated e-cigarette products, with disposable devices a favorite of suppliers because of their price and relative ease of being counterfeited. In fact, about 45% of the market is made up of these devices, despite questionable provenance, raw materials and manufacturing.
Suppliers seize the opportunity to purchase inferior disposable products and offer them as legitimate products, increasing profits at the expense of consumer safety. "In the informal market, for some suppliers, the only thing they need is proper regulation; However, the lack of this can lead to market manipulation by a small number of distributors who can change prices at will, "Tomas noted, recalling that cases of fraud at the hands of fake virtual stores are often common.
Challenges to organized civil society
Panama's current problems are the prohibition policy and the apparent lack of interest in controlling cigarette smuggling, which is a major pillar of the consumption epidemic and why the government claims that the results of the control may be incomplete. As mentioned earlier, the latter is due to the significant price difference between the formal market and the black market, as consumption accounting is based on the number of units legally sold, but the majority of the smoking population chooses the informal market because of its price.
This, together with precarious education policies, has encouraged young people to degenerate and continue to use tobacco. In a survey of 2,096 students aged 13 to 15, about 8% admitted to smoking, while another 6.4% said they used e-cigarettes. In addition, 17 percent claimed to have smoked secondhand smoke in their homes, and more than 31 percent smoked in enclosed public places.
Yet all was not lost. With bill 178 of 2021 on the verge of approval, it is possible to advocate for a more appropriate way to regulate panama's e-cigarette industry groups, despite pressure from economic groups associated with the tobacco industry and strange anti-smoking/anti-e-cigarette interests.
Panama's Association for Smoking Harm Reduction (ARDTP) has taken the voice of e-cigarette users to the government's ears, while also defending smokers' right to free access to the less harmful technology. Thanks to this, they even managed to veto prohibitive bills. Formed and led by Tomas Sanchez (president) and Victor Reyes, a lawyer, the association has been dealing with the legal issues of e-cigarettes before the government.
At present, the association has the ability to increase its human resources to remain at the forefront of consumer interests and rights. They can be reached through their social networks, where updates, news and information about the local and global e-cigarette situation can also be found. The association's @ardtPanama can be found on Twitter, @ardtPanama on Instagram and the messaging platform is open to address Panamanians' concerns.

