Doctors should consider regular e-cigarettes as non-pharmaceutical products for smoking cessation and harm reduction

May 27, 2022 Leave a message

An earlier edition of The Tobacco Report described widespread false concerns around the world about the health risks of nicotine -- people often trust their doctors to provide health information. The same is true for smokers.

The data suggest that smokers trust their doctors over other sources of information about e-cigarettes, and that most patients who use e-cigarettes would appreciate at least a brief discussion.

Can doctors take advantage of that trust? Can they effectively steer patients who can't or won't quit to a life-saving alternative to smoking? Getting patients to quit smoking is a top priority.

Cigarettes remain the leading preventable cause of illness and death in the United States and many other countries. Smoking rates have stagnated among vulnerable groups, including the elderly, those on low incomes or those with chronic physical or mental illness.

Thanks in part to media concerns about lung damage from vaping and bans on e-cigarette flavors, the decline in cigarette sales is actually rising. Before doctors can help, they must have accurate information and be convinced that action is necessary.

Doctors are confused about nicotine

One big hurdle is the widespread belief among doctors that nicotine is dangerous. The first sentence of the 2021 investigation in the Journal of General Internal Medicine states, "Nicotine is responsible for the highly addictive properties of tobacco products, but most tobacco-induced illnesses are not caused directly by nicotine, but by other chemicals present in tobacco or tobacco smoke." Surprisingly, four out of five doctors in the US survey strongly agreed that nicotine causes cancer, cardiovascular disease and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. There are only minor differences between medical specialties. Recent national surveys have found similar findings.

How might this affect doctors' willingness to recommend nicotine replacement therapy to patients who smoke? What about nicotine products?

Continuity of risk

Another obstacle is ignorance or fear of non-pharmaceutical harm reduction products. A 2020 review by the University of Queensland 8 found 45 qualitative and quantitative studies internationally looking at doctors' perceptions and practices of electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS). Doctors know about ENDS, but experts are far behind on its health effects and uses for smoking cessation. Most of what they know comes from media reports or patients.

The April 2022 JAMA Network Open.9 Rutgers University authors surveyed 2,058 board-certified physicians across the country in the latest and largest U.S. study on physicians' perceptions of patients about e-cigarettes. The conclusion was that "more than half of physicians believe that all tobacco products are equally harmful, and this belief is associated with lower rates of e-cigarette recommendations." "It is critical to address physicians' misconceptions about nicotine and correct misconceptions about the relative harm of various tobacco products," the authors argue, because the "FDA authorization process" has introduced more modified risk products.

An earlier study by Rutgers university researchers involving structured interviews with doctors gave reason to be skeptical. Most of the doctors they spoke to were at least neutral to attempts to switch to e-cigarettes by patients who had failed with traditional smoking cessation methods.

But five of the 35 doctors firmly opposed it; Even if future randomized controlled trials find that e-cigarettes are equal to or better than other methods of quitting smoking, they do not recommend e-cigarettes for patients. One oncologist said, "Based on what I've heard and read about them, I don't think so. Like I said, they're actually kind of dangerous."

A close reading showed that doctors who believed e-cigarettes could be an effective conversion tool -- about half of respondents -- were convinced by a combination of stories and data. Patients, friends or family members use e-cigarettes to reduce or quit smoking.